Original Article

Comparative Study of Five Blood Cardioplegia Systems

Division of Circulation Technology, School of Allied Medical Professions, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio

^* Address correspondence to: Philip D. Beckley, PhD, Division of Circulation Technology, School of Allied Medical Professions, The Ohio State University, 1583 Perry Street, Columbus, OH 43210

Abstract

Five blood cardioplegia delivery systems (Gish Straight Shot, Sorin BCD Advanced, A vecor MYOtherm, Baxter-Bentley HE-30, and Baxter-Bentley HE-30 Gold) were evaluated with respect to ease of rapid priming, coefficient of heat exchange, pressure drop, bubble trap capacity, and priming volume. Each system was placed in a roller pump circuit consisting of source and collection reservoirs, cardioplegia solution, and pre-post system pressure and temperature monitoring sites. A trial was performed on four units of each brand by first priming the circuit with 0.9% NaCI at 200 ml/min. Bovine blood (hematocrit 22%) was then introduced simulating use during bypass. Pressure drops across the heat exchanger were measured at flows of 200, 300, and 400 ml/min and at temperatures of 37°, 19°, and 4°C. Coefficient of heat exchange was determined at 300 ml/min flow. Air was infused into the system to quantify the bubble trap capacity of the heat exchanger module. Priming volume of the entire system and of the heat exchanger module were determined by draining each into a graduated cylinder.

The Sorin system had significantly less priming volume when compared to all others. The HE-30 units had significantly higher heat exchange coefficients compared to all other systems. Variability was noted in pressure drop at the highest flows and lowest temperatures.